Showing posts with label Jake Delhomme. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jake Delhomme. Show all posts

March 15, 2010

Thoughts on the Brady and Wimbley Trades...

Fans who demanded change this off-season have certainly gotten their wish. The Cleveland Browns have been extremely active thus far in the off-season making moves via free agency and trade. So far the Browns have signed Scott Fujita, Tony Pashos, Ben Watson and Jake Delhomme in addition to parting ways with Brady Quinn, Corey Williams, Derek Anderson, and Kamerion Wimbley.

The Brady Quinn trade should come as no surprise. The signing of Jake Delhomme to a $7 million per year deal clearly indicated that Brady was expendable. Fans are angry and confused at the money thrown to Delhomme, but keep in mind that this is an uncapped year and the deal is incentive loaded. I like the Delhomme signing. I think he had a terrible year in 2008, but so did Brady and DA. Delhomme has terrific experience and has had good success while in Carolina. He is year removed from surgery and I expect that a change of scenery will do wonders for Delhomme. I do not see him as a long term answer, but as a solid player to hold down the fort while the new regime looks at QB's in the draft either this year or next. Next year's draft looks to be loaded at the QB position, if we don't find our guy this year. Delhomme gives us flexibility at the position without giving up valuable draft picks.

While trading Quinn was inevitable, I am skeptical that we received enough in return. The Browns received Peyton Hillis, a BIG RB/FB, who I think will be productive in Cleveland. In addition, we received a 6th in the 2011 draft and a conditional late round pick in 2010. Brady Quinn is a good team player and I like him a lot. I wish he would have performed in Cleveland, but his inability to stay on the field hampered his development. Of course, the way he was handled by the organization over the last 2 years played a huge role in ruining the early years of his career. One problem I have with Browns fans are that they are too loyal to local products. Brady Quinn is from Dublin, Ohio, near Columbus. He grew up a Browns fan, and while that is nice, I don't really care if he can't help the team win. The bottom line with Quinn is that he was not an accurate passer, a trait that is probably the most important in making a successful NFL QB. People questioned his arm strength, but the bigger problem was his accuracy, even on short and intermediate routes. I appreciate what Brady Quinn tried to do in Cleveland and I appreciate his comments upon leaving Cleveland. He wished the team well, had only good things to say about the Browns and went out of his way to say how great the fans are. (Take a hint DA, that's why you got booed you a-hole)

The Kamerion Wimbley trade I do not feel as good about. Wimbley had a great rookie season and looked as if he was returning to form. I think the Browns thought they should trade him while his value was high, but I think a mid 3rd is not enough in return. I don't think Wimbley is a pro-bowl type of player, but he was productive as a pass-rusher and was improving every year in coverage and against the run. The Browns must have thought that it was the scheme that generated the second highest sack total recorded by the team since its the return and not any one-on-one mismatch created by Wimbley. In a sense I agree, I saw pressure come from everywhere when the defense was playing disciplined. However, I would not have traded Wimbley for less than a second rounder. It will be interesting to see if the Browns use this arsenal of picks to move on draft day or to target a Restricted Free Agent. Kamerion also had good things to say on his way out the door, so I guess I'll hope he does well too.


March 14, 2010

Dude, We're Getting a Delhomme!

Last evening, the Browns signed quarterback Jake Delhomme, formerly of the Carolina Panthers, marking the Holmgren regime's most curious move thusfar.  Delhomme was once a servicable starter and lead the Panthers to the Super Bowl in 2003.  Otherwise, Delhomme is a very average NFL quarterback.  His career rating is a pedestrian 82.1 and last season it plummeted to 59.4 coming off Tommy John (Tommy J!) surgery.  Perhaps he can rebound a bit being a year removed from the procedure, but this is obviously not a long term solution.  Being a proponent of trading for Donovan McNabb, I was disappointed to hear this news yesterday.  This signing seems to reveal that that ship has sailed and that the Browns will go in another direction at quarterback, likely addressing the future at the position in the upcoming draft.

One player to keep an eye on is Colt McCoy.  The "Godfather" Gil Brandt, talent evaluator extrodinaire apparently told Mike Holmgren recently that if he took McCoy he would one day make him forget about Joe Montana, lofty praise for the little spark plug.  But I do like Colt.  His career completion percentage is over 70% at Texas. He's a gritty leader. accurate and mobile.  The only questionmarks on McCoy are his durability, being of smaller stature and suffering a shoulder injury in the National Championship game, and his arm strength.  McCoy would be targeted with our second round pick.

I ran into Les Levine at brunch this morning at Pier W in Lakewood, who had an interesting take on the ever evolving saga at the Brown's quarterback position.  He told me that of all the breakfast's he's eaten, today's was the most recent.

-Charlie

March 10, 2010

DA gone and I wanna Delhomme?


According to multiple sources, Jake Delhomme of the Carolina Panthers will be in Berea tomorrow visiting the Browns.